The Senate has passed a bill that is directly related to prediction markets for the first time since the products became mainstream, voting Thursday to approve legislation that codifies a ban on markets related to war, assassination, terrorism, or death.
The DEATH BETS Act, introduced by Sen. Adam Schiff, says that Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)-registered entities cannot list contracts for trading if the contract “expressly references” terrorism, assassination, war, United States Armed Forces military operations, or “any similar activity,” as determined by the CFTC.
The bill also bans any contract that “is reasonably expected to resolve principally based on a death of an individual.”
The full name of the bill is the “Discouraging Exploitative Assassination, Tragedy, and Harm Betting in Event Trading Systems Act.”
Bill finds new life post-midterms
The bill was introduced all the way back in March and assigned to the Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition, and Forestry. It appeared to stuck in that committee after more than eight months without movement.
However, it gained new life in the Senate’s lame-duck period, after the midterm elections that will change control of the chamber. It was approved by the committee by unanimous consent Thursday, and then by the whole Senate by voice vote, also indicating overwhelming or unanimous support, on the same day.
Now passed by the Senate, the bill will now have to be approved by the House to become law. There is already a sister bill in the House, which was introduced in April and referred to the Subcommittee on Commodity Markets, Digital Assets, and Rural Development.
CFTC rules on death contracts
No CFTC-regulated exchange currently lists contracts directly related to war, assassination, or terrorism, and it appears unlikely that the CFTC as it stands would allow them to be listed. However, there is no statutory ban on these contracts, and the existing CFTC regulations that appear to ban these contracts have been subject to alternative interpretations.
Contracts “involving” war, assassination, and terrorism appear to be banned by the CFTC’s Rule 40.11, which says exchanges “shall not” list contracts that involve those topics or gaming.
However, the ban does not exist in statute — the Commodity Exchange Act only says that the CFTC “may” stop exchanges from listing contracts involving these categories if it determines them to be against the public interest — meaning any ban could be overturned by future CFTC rulemaking without congressional input.
In addition, lawyers for Kalshi have argued that the CFTC’s Rule 40.11 is not actually a ban, as some clauses of the rules appear to suggest ways in which the contracts could still be listed. Former CFTC Commissioner Brian Quintenz argued in 2021 that 40.11 is an "unconstitutional" and “invalid” rule and should be ignored, because Congress told the CFTC to make case-by-case decisions on contracts covering these topics, not a blanket rule.
Rule 40.11 is set to be changed via a CFTC rulemaking process, to be replaced with a rule that clearly states that the CFTC categorically views war, assassination, and terrorism markets as against the public interest, while contracts involving gaming would depend on the circumstances. It is not clear whether Quintenz’s criticisms of 40.11 could still apply to the new rule, absent a new law from Congress.
Recommended

