8 min

What Is A Swap? Kalshi, Polymarket, Tribes, Casinos, And Cboe Debate Proposed CFTC Definitions

Taking a closer look at responses to the CFTC rulemaking on the definition of a swap

by Daniel O'Boyle

Last updated: November 19, 2026

Can a swap include sports event contracts while simultaneously excluding sportsbook bets? Does drawing a line between the two help or hurt tribes? Can contracts on single stocks be swaps? Is there a way to carve out friendly wagers, and avoid turning two friends making a bet at a bar into unregistered swap dealers? Those topics were debated by prediction markets, tribes, casinos, and giants of traditional finance in rulemaking comments submitted to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Wednesday.

The CFTC last month proposed two new sets of rules around the definition of a swap, a type of financial instrument defined in the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and traditionally used for hedging risk. The first one states that event contracts, including sports event contracts, are swaps, while the second says that sportsbook bets and casino games are not swaps.

The CFTC proposed a “provider test” and a “product test” with neither one alone deciding whether a product is a swap or not. The provider test is that swaps are offered by federally regulated designated contract markets (DCMs), whereas sportsbook bets are offered by gaming operators licensed by state gaming commissions or by Native American tribes. The product test is that swaps are offered on a peer-to-peer exchange where prices are determined by market forces rather than being made against the house, and are tradable.

As part of the rulemaking process, the CFTC opened a request for comments on its new rules. Comments were due at the end of the day Wednesday.

Kalshi agrees on key points

Kalshi’s response agreed with the CFTC’s plans on all major points. Kalshi Chief Compliance Officer Sudhir Jain wrote that event contracts are already “known to the trade as ‘swaps,” which is one of the prongs of the definition of a swap in the CEA. It added that the CEA gives the CFTC and Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) the authority to “further define” swap.

“Put differently, Kalshi agrees with the Commission that the critical defining features of a swap, consistent with the purpose of the CEA, are the operational foundations of how the instrument is structured, bought, and sold,” Jain’s letter said. “And Kalshi agrees with the Commission that, just as was true with respect to insurance products, nothing suggests that Congress intended for the Commission to regulate casino or gambling style wagers that are not structured, bought, or sold as derivatives.” 

Jain added that the exclusion of sportsbook wagers from the definition would “dispel the erroneous premise that, if event contracts are swaps, then casino-style gambling products and sportsbook bets must also be swaps.” The idea that making sports event contracts swaps would mean sportsbook bets must be unlicensed swaps has been argued in states’ legal briefs against Kalshi.

Jain noted that the rule would also allow federal authorities to take action against sports betting operators that are not licensed by either the CFTC or state gaming boards, while still also permitting state authorities to take action against the same businesses.

The one change Kalshi did request was an explicit definition of the term “event contract,” in order to also cover event contracts that are structured as futures contracts rather than swaps.  

Letters from companies hedging on Kalshi

A number of organizations that hedge risk on Kalshi also submitted letters.

Angelo Ferro, founder and CEO of Playably, says his business uses Kalshi’s contracts to help companies arrange and then hedge the risk of promotions based on sporting outcomes. Mitch Hull, who is the managing general partner of a Pepsi bottling and distribution company, said his company uses Kalshi to hedge risks related to fuel prices. Ice cream shop owner James Jiang said he used Kalshi contracts to hedge weather risks.

All three argued that these use cases support the idea that prediction market contracts meet the definition of a swap. 

AGs: Sports contracts, bets can’t be split

A group of 44 state attorneys general and the attorney general for the District of Columbia submitted a letter arguing that the proposed definition of swap “rests on a legal fiction.”

“Neither the text of the CEA nor judicial precedent supports splitting gambling products into federal ‘swaps’ and state ‘casino’ wagers based on whether a bet is matched against a peer or placed against a house,” the letter said.

The attorneys general also wrote that “No rational claim can be made that betting against the house affects the public interest differently than wagering against a fellow bettor.”   

The lead author on the letter was Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown, who secured a major legal win Tuesday when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled that Maryland can enforce its sports betting laws against Kalshi.

The six states that were not represented on the brief were Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Montana, New Hampshire, and Texas. 

Dozens of tribes oppose rules

Many Native American tribes and tribal organizations submitted responses, largely critical of the rules for including sports event contracts as swaps. For example, the Mohegan Tribe of Connecticut wrote that permission to “further define” the word swap does not give the CFTC the power to “broaden the definition of swap.”

The Iowa Tribe of Oklahoma wrote that “by attempting to displace tribal regulatory authority through an administrative process, the Rulemakings collide directly with constitutional principles, federal Indian law, and Congress’s express intent under the CEA and the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act.”

The Indian Gaming Association called the logic behind the CFTC’s inclusion of sports contracts as swaps “absurd.”

“Under this logic, any type of event contract could serve as a swap,” it said. “It is rare that any activity or event has no potential economic consequence, so this interpretation would allow almost anything to be classified as a swap, directly conflicting with Congress’ intent in drafting the Special Rule.” 

In total, 45 tribes or tribal organizations submitted letters, almost all opposed to the CFTC considering sports contracts to be swaps. 

But a few tribes in support

However, a few tribes backed the rulemaking. The Tunica-Biloxi tribe of Louisiana, the Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town of Oklahoma, and both the Alturas Indian Rancheria and the Greenville Rancheria of California have partnerships with Kalshi that allow the tribe to offer Kalshi’s sports event contracts. Those four tribes all submitted letters that broke with other tribes on their stances on the rules.     

Tunica-Biloxi Chair Marshall Pierite argued that withdrawing the proposed rules would return Indian Country “to the ambiguity that made the rule necessary, and it would do so at a moment when litigation over these questions is active.”   

He argued that sports event contracts and the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA) can coexist, and called for the preamble to the rules to include an express statement “that the rules do not alter IGRA, any Tribal gaming ordinance or Tribal-State compact, or the jurisdiction of Tribal governments and Tribal gaming regulators over gaming on Indian lands.”

Non-Kalshi exchanges mostly back CFTC

Polymarket US’s and Novig’s representatives largely agreed with the CFTC’s plans, but both found some narrow areas where they felt the rules could be improved. Both expressed concern that the rules as written could potentially include private wagers between friends as unlicensed swaps, and sought rules that would clarify that this is not the case.

“Congress did not intend to require friends to use a designated contract market to bet on football,” Novig’s letter said. “The Commission should add a narrow category for incidental social wagers made directly between individuals, where neither is in the business of accepting wagers or offering exposure to others.” 

Polymarket US suggested a similar rule, adding that the bet should also not be “offered to the public nor entered into through a trading facility or commercial gaming operator.”

Underdog’s Chief Legal Officer Nick Lundgren wrote a letter emphasizing the “commonly known to the trade” argument, pointing out that Underdog has self-certified its event contracts as swaps, and offered users access to event contracts from other exchanges which were also listed as swaps.

Rothera CEO Thomas Chippas also submitted a letter backing the main points in the CFTC’s proposed rules.

Cboe wants protection on stock contracts

Traditional commodities and options giant Cboe expressed concern about the rules, particularly around contracts related to securities.

Cboe General Counsel Patrick Sexton wrote that the SEC was only a “footnote” in the proposed rules, despite Congress saying that the CFTC and SEC can “jointly define” swap.

Sexton added that any event contract about a single stock should be excluded from the swap definition. 

Cboe last month launched SEC-regulated prediction market contracts on companies’ key performance indicators.

AGA questions CFTC volume figure

Besides its general objection to sports event contracts being classed as swaps, the American Gaming Association (AGA) also honed in on one detail of the CFTC’s proposed rules.

The CFTC’s proposals state that “In August 2026, average monthly trading volume in event contracts was about $1.5 billion across all DCMs reporting to the Commission.” 

As the AGA, a gambling industry group, pointed out, $1.5 billion is a tiny fraction of the total volume traded on CFTC-regulated prediction markets in August, which exceeded $40 billion. It questioned whether the CFTC was equipped to regulate the industry if it did not appear to be aware of how much money was traded on event contracts. 

The figure may have been intended to represent the average event contract volume per DCM, which would work out at around $1.5 billion if all licensed DCMs are included. However, many DCMs don’t over event contracts at all, and among those who do, almost all the volume in August came from two or three exchanges.

Boyd: Casino games not fully excluded

Casino operator Boyd Gaming also submitted a letter arguing that the proposed definitions do not sufficiently exclude casino games. It said that by attempting to exclude casino games based in part on who offers them, the rule opens the door to a DCM offering casino games that count as swaps.

It argued that many risks hedged through event contracts are self-created, due to promotions, and that the same logic could be used to argue that casino games have financial consequences.

“if Caribou Coffee’s buy-one-get-one deal for each Vikings interception creates an economic consequence sufficient to justify an event contract trading on the underlying interceptions, a casino bettor’s wager that the roulette ball will land on black equally justifies an event contract trading on the outcome of the underlying roulette spin,” the letter said.

Boyd argued that the rulemaking needed to unambiguously state that casino games cannot be swaps.

“Such an express, categorical exclusion would clarify that traditional casino games are not, in any respect, under the Commission’s authority,” the letter said. “It would also close the door to creative new casino-game operators masquerading as CFTC-regulated DCMs.”

Ex-CFTC nominee Quintenz backs rules

Brian Quintenz — the Kalshi director and former CFTC commissioner who was nominated in 2025 to chair the agency before his nomination was withdrawn — submitted a letter backing the rules. 

Quintenz argued that the CFTC’s rulemaking uses the same authority that was used when the agency excluded insurance contracts from the definition of a swap. 

He added that it was “dishonest to say” that sports event contracts do not have financial consequences, and that sports event contracts “cannot be distinguished” from other categories of event contract.

“State-regulated gambling and federally regulated event contracts can exist in tandem. The [rules] draw the line between them on a principled basis: the inclusion confirms what belongs inside the federal framework, and the exclusion confirms what does not,” he wrote. “The CFTC’s regulation of swaps involving the economic impact of sporting events on DCMs in no way hinders states’ ability to regulate their own intra-state businesses offering wagers gambling products with house-set odds.”

Other figures linked to major prediction markets, such as Kalshi investors Andreessen Horowitz and Paradigm, also submitted letters supporting the rules.